Fixed Price valuation clauses are the easiest to administer, but the value may not be remotely close to the true market value. Disputes between owners will arise if a … As you might expect, the valuation clause dictates how the company’s … Office Hours: M-F 8:00am - 5:00pm. Gryphon Valuation Consultants, Inc. www.BizVals.com 702-870-VALU (8258) Buy/Sell Agreements provide a blueprint for the transfer of business interests, allowing business owners to control and protect their investment in an organized and prescribed manner. document.getElementById('loginOrJoin').innerHTML = "Sign In"; The re are numerous objectives for such an agreement . While this agreement is easy to understand, fixed price agreements essentially become obsolete by the time the ink dries. Looking for an Electrical Contractor or Work? Common Valuation Formulas for Buy-Sell Agreements Option 1 – Book Value. • Valuation language is not clear and leaves room for interpretation; the valuation provision is inappropriate; or the valuation provision is dead wrong! A buy-sell agreement should contain a valuation clause that sets forth a procedure to definitively establish the price to be paid when a triggering event occurs. The Benefits of an Independent Valuation . The valuation multiple in a formula agreement presents the same issues as a fixed price agreement since the multiple does not change with changes in business and market conditions. var o = document.getElementById("__ClientContext"); Buy-sell agreements are designed to provide a market for the shares of the departing shareholder, to protect the value of a significant asset, to meet estate planning objectives, to establish a price and terms for the shares and to establish a funding mechanism for a buyout. Crafting a precise definition of the accounting information that will be used is imperative, and challenging. He has been a SCACPA speaker on the topic of International Tax Updates. Depending on the asset profile of a company, adjusted book value can serve as a relatively straightforward valuation approach, relatively safe from challenge when used in a buy-sell agreement. Agreements are signed, stored away, and collect dust until the day they are needed. In this case, the agreement provided that the value of the company for the purpose of a member’s retirement was the value specified in a “Certificate of Agreed Value.” The Operating Agreement further provided that the members were to meet once a year to update the value and that the value of any individual member’s int… For example, if the formula is four times “net income,” the owners could manipulate the value to whatever they desire (e.g. Oftentimes, agreements are established with good intentions but limited knowledge. Clients are naturally influenced by their desire for a conclusion favorable to them.3 The purpose of process buy-sell agreements, however, regardless of their limitations, is to reach reasonable conclusions. Unlike a fixed price agreement, the accounting information used in a formula agreement does change as a business operates. A Buy/Sell Agreement helps a business owner “lock in” a value for the business by using a “valuation formula.” The formula you use could mean the difference between receiving liquidation value or fair market value. Formula Agreements are easy to understand and relatively simple to apply. AKA “net worth or owner’s equity” is simply the total assets minus the total liabilities as shown on your financial statement. Using a Formula to Determine a Business’ Value for a Buy-Sell Agreement. Customizing and Funding the Buy-Sell Agreement. Think of the Buy/Sell Agreement … There is sometimes an appraiser named in the agreement, but most of the time a process is established to identify a qualified appraiser in the future. • Critical elements of the agreement have been overlooked and left out. This new value is then amended in the Buy/Sell Agreement. But privately held businesses do not have a ready market for owners to transfer interests in the business. Share valuation formulas often involve using either: (a) the book value ofthe shares; or. Issues, What Issues? The section of a buy-sell agreement that addresses the worth of the company shares is known as the valuation clause. In many buy-sell agreements, the buyout clause for shares of privately-held stock is determined by a valuation formula, such as “shares will be purchased at a 4 or 5 times multiple of the company’s most recent year EBITDA … Preparing for the inevitable should be common sense, but it is one of the more neglected aspects of financial planning. •  Fair Market value of ABC Inc. = $1.4 million The valuation clause in a buy-sell agreement is one of the key provisions in the agreement and must be carefully drafted to avoid surprises or disputes. III. It is when a partnership does not have pre-existing buyout language in the agreement that determining valuation can become problematic. document.getElementById('loginOrJoin').href = j.websiteRoot + "MEA_Archive/Contact_Management/Sign_In.aspx"; • Ownership interests diverge over time, especially when “trigger events” occur. Buy Sell. 100% money-back guarantee. These agreements call for a valuation process in order to determine the value of a business, but there is generally no prescribed formula in the agreement. Multiple appraiser buy-sell agreements … Some of the elements that the parties may wish to specify in the Shareholder Buy / Sell Agreement include: Designating a specific valuator (e.g. if (o) { It is critical that the pricing mechanism in a valuation process buy-sell agreement be specified without any ambiguity.   •  Loss in Value = $600,000, Option 3 – Appraised Fair Market Value Method This Buy-Sell Agreement ... would be made (i) for value, or (ii) to … Option 1 – Book Value A buy-sell agreement is a contractual agreement among the owners of a business (i.e., the shareholders of a corporation, the partners of a partnership, or the members of an limited liability company) which restricts the right to transfer the ownership interests and establishes certain purchase and sale rights and obligations upon the occurrence of certain events. A buy–sell agreement, also known as a buyout agreement, is a legally binding agreement between co-owners of a business that governs the situation if a co-owner dies or is otherwise forced to leave the business, or chooses to leave the business. Sec. However, the actual language suggested otherwise. { 19 98)). Template language to assist attorneys in drafting the valuation portions of client buy-sell agreements; The information and guidance found in this book has been the result of decades of experience working with hundreds of buy-sell agreements and participating in dozens of (mostly flawed) valuation … A buy-sell agreement can be a flexible as the owners wish it to be.   •  Loss in Value = $0. May 16, 2014. Another option is to have the shareholders agree on a value each year. The Form of the Agreement. Issues to be Addressed. Process Agreements detail how the business will be valued in the future. This Buy-Sell Agreement (this "Agreement") is made effective as of _____, between and among _____ (the "Company") and each of the individuals listed on the attached Schedule A (each an "Owner," and collectively, the "Owners"). Different methods of valuation can be applied over the life cycle of the business. A buy/sell agreement is a contract between the members of an LLC that provides for the sale (or offer to sell) of a member 's interest in the business to the other members or to the LLC when a specified event or events occur. A fixed price agreement states the value of the business on the date the agreement is signed. Such structured negotiations can take the form of an agreed-upon value … An initial benchmark valuation can take fear and mystery out of the valuation process for the shareholders. Transfers of interests are inevitable, and businesses must plan in advance to ensure operations are not interrupted when interests are transferred. Sample Buy-Sell Agreement Sample Buy-Sell Agreement Section 1: Introduction The legal existence of the company shall not terminate upon the addition of a new owner or the transfer of an owner's interest under this agreement… Buy and sell agreements may also establish a method for determining the value of a business. A buy-sell clause outlines a process and pricing mechanism for the sale of the shares of a departing shareholder (e.g. Dustin Scott is a manager with the CPA firm of McGregor & Company, LLP in the firm’s Columbia office. A multi-appraiser approach is more common with large companies and joint ventures. } Jeff Allen is a partner at Burr Forman McNair whose practice focuses on corporate and tax matters. try { To prevent manipulation, net income must be precisely defined and address issues such as net income before/after tax or net income before owner’s compensation. Disputes between owners will arise if a buy-sell agreement fails to include a procedure to definitively establish the value of the business. 1300 12th Street, Suite D | Cayce, SC 29033, Copyright 2018 South Carolina CPA’s | All Rights Reserved, Buy-Sell Agreements: Don’t Sleep on the Valuation Clause, on Buy-Sell Agreements: Don’t Sleep on the Valuation Clause. } Buy/Sell Agreements: A Business Valuation Perspective By: Donald R. Parker, CFA, CVA Buy/Sell Agreements provide a blueprint for the transfer of business interests, allowing business owners to control and protect their investment in an organized and prescribed manner. Valuation Methods for Buy-Sell Agreements. They provide a defined structure or process for determining the price at which future transactions will occur. Think of the Buy/Sell Agreement … •  Fair Marketing Value of ABC Inc. = $1.4 million Fixed Price Agreements, Formula Agreements and Process Agreements represent the most commonly used methods to establish the value of a business under a buy-sell agreement. jQuery(document).ready(function () { (a) From and after the date that is the earlier of (i) three (3) years from the Opening Date or (ii) five (5) years from the date hereof, SWA, on the one hand, or MHG, on the other hand, may, subject to … As noted above, buy-sell agreements will generally contain a valuation clause with the terms of the buyout and, often, a definition of value. Ct. Aug. 4, 2009). Take advantage of Federated’s Agreement EvaluatorSM to receive an informal review on the strengths and weaknesses of your valuation formula along with the other terms of your Buy/Sell Agreement. The “Accountable” Podcast for CFOs: Harnessing the Power of Data, Surgent’s On-Demand Self-Study Offers SCACPA Members the Specific CPE You Need With More than 230 Courses, Get a Jump on Being a Voice: SCACPA Has Opened Nominations for 2021-22 Board of Directors and Chapter Leadership Positions, SCACPA Student Scholarship Applications are Open as of Dec. 1 for the 2021-22 Academic Year. A Buy/Sell Agreement helps a business owner “lock in” a value for the business by using a “valuation formula.” The formula you use could mean the difference between receiving liquidation value or fair market value. Minneapolis, MN 55408 A critical component of any agreement is the process by which the price is determined. Disputes often arise when a business has grown substantially over time and the fixed price agreement value is no longer remotely close to the true market value. •  Appraised Fair Market Value of ABC Inc. = $1.4M If you utilize this type, how long has it been since you documented a new value? Attorneys should periodically review the terms of buy-out agreements with owners to determine if the original agreement … Appraiser Qualifications Without specifying any qualifying criteria, anyone could be called upon to determine the price of the ompany’s shares or membership interests when a triggering event occurs. Buy-sell agreements fall into three basic categories: fixed-price agreements, formula agreements, and agree-ments requiring the performance of a valuation. In my opinion, most shareholder disputes regarding share valuation could have been avoided had the buy-sell valuation language been drafted with the help of a valuation professional. document.getElementById('loginOrJoin').href = j.websiteRoot + "Online/Membership/Join_Now/Online/Membership/Join_Now.aspx";   •  Book Value = $450,000 Docket No. The book value method (also known as net worth or owner’s equity) is simply the total assets minus the total liabilities of the business. The agreement can … Once a redemption right has been exercised by the majority owner or a put right has been invoked by the minority investor, the second critical issue in negotiating the buy-sell agreement is how the parties will determine the value (purchase price) for the minority interest. Common events triggering a buy/sell agreement … Critical Valuation Issues For All Buy/Sell Agreements [Brian Bornino] Case Studies Slide 29 – Slide 33 Slide 34 – Slide 56 [Brian Bornino and Kelly Noll] Related-Party Buy/Sell Issues [Jim Alerding] Best Practices And Recommendations Slide 69 – Slide 75 Slide 57 – Slide 68 [Brian Bornino] 6. The valuation clause in a shareholder agreement is critical so take great care in deciding what yours should be. A lot of Buy Sell Agreements use a common valuation method called the “fixed price” method. This test is met if more than 50% of the value of the business subject to the buy-sell agreement is owned directly or indirectly by individuals who are not members of the decedent’s family and ownership interests are subject to the same binding buy-sell agreement terms. upon death, disability, retirement, etc.) In Lauder and True, the court disregarded book value set forth in buy-sell agreements between related parties for estate tax valuation purposes. The Buy-Sell Agreement1 Whenever a corporation has more than one shareholder, it is commonly recommended that the shareholders enter into a buy-sell agreement to operate in the event of a shareholder's death, disability, retirement, or conflict with other shareholders or a number of other specific circumstances. There is one certainty in business – ownership relationships are not permanent. 3. Then the buy/sell agreement … The purpose of the Partnership was to provide income to … Three Common Valuation Formulas: Option 1 – Book Value The IRS may also challenge the value established in a buy/sell agreement when it appears the decedent was attempting to transfer property for less than full consideration (a partial disguised gift) to a nonfamily me mber (Gloeckner, 152 F.3d 208 (2d Cir. Methods for Assessing a Business’ Value . Emotions tend to run high when owners face a “triggering event” that activates the […] The agreement must have terms comparable to those of similar arrangements entered into by persons in an arm’s-length transaction. Process Agreement valuation clauses will lead to the best estimate of market value but are the costliest valuation clause to administer. This method is sometimes referred to as the liquidation method and often understates the true fair market value … A buy-sell agreement will typically provide for an assessment of the business’ value in one of three ways: An agreed-upon value; Fair market value at the time of …   •  Loss in value = $950,000, Option 2 – Agreed Value Method These agreements blend accounting information and valuation multiples to establish a value for the business. Every business with more than one owner needs a buy-sell agreement to handle both expected and unexpected ownership changes. (a) From and after the date that is the earlier of (i) three (3) years from the Opening Date or (ii) five (5) years from the date hereof, SWA, on the one hand, or MHG, on the other hand, may, subject to the provisions of the documents underlying or securing a financing of the Property, elect to make a purchase offer pursuant to the provisions of this Section 7.3. If no valuation has been agreed on within two years before the date of the event requiring an agreement on value, the value of a selling Shareholder’s interest shall be agreed on by the selling Shareholder or his or her successor in interest and the remaining Shareholders. 3100 Humboldt Ave S VALUATION s BUY-SELL AGREEMENTS FROM A VALUATION PERSPECTIVE The buy-sell agreement can also be structured to vary depending on the triggering purchase event. Product or Service Members? Looking for an Electrical Contractor or Work? by issuing bonuses to the owners). Buy/sell agreements fix that problem by creating a market among the owners of a company, providing a mechanism for owners to liquidate their interests in a reliable manner. THIS BUY-SELL AGREEMENT (the “Agreement”) is made, entered into and effective as of the day of , 2015, by and between ... $0.001 par value per share (the “Class A Common Stock” and, with the Class B Common Stock (as defined below), the “Company Stock”); and . Lee v. Meloan, No. Buy-sell agreements are commonly used to address transfers by identifying when or what events prompt a buyout, identifying how a buyout will be funded, and identifying the timing of a buyout. This method ensures all interested parties receive the full value they deserve. Section 2703(a) states that a shareholder agreement … Formula approach. Multiple appraiser buy-sell agreements have advantages. In this situation, many partnerships turn toward independent … Poorly drafted and ambiguous buy-sell agreements … When creating or updating yours, be sure you’re prepared for the valuation issues that will come into play. Formula Agreement valuation clauses can provide a close approximation to true market value but must be carefully drafted and reviewed regularly. }); Electrical Association  (map) All parties to the agreements know, at least generally, what the process will entail. It is important to consider the requirements of Internal Revenue Code (IRC) Section 2703 when developing an estate plan involving business interests in which 50% or more of the stock is family owned.. } Some agreements call for a "valuation formula" which is agreed to by the shareholders at the time the agreement is drafted. document.getElementById('loginOrJoin').innerHTML = "Join"; View any of our directories below! Product or Service Members? The anticipated business operations and funds available for planning typically dictate which formula a business will use to establish value. Valuation of LLC or Member’s Interest Proposed Language: In the event of the sale of the LLC, or ... Board of Directors are unable to reach agreement on fair market value within such 30‐day period, either may cause the determination of fair market value to be made in accordance with the Appraisal Procedure. Owners periodically meet and set the value of the business in writing. terms of the agreement, the estate tax value of the equity can be fixed in the estate of a deceased owner. While this brings some certainty to the value, it is difficult to capture in a formula all the factors that determine value. A buyout agreement, also known as a buy-sell agreement, is a legal contract between the owners of a business that sets out how the future sale or buyout of an owner's interest in the business will be handled. It is important to consider the requirements of Internal Revenue Code (IRC) Section 2703 when developing an estate plan involving business interests in which 50% or more of the stock is family owned.. This dispute involved a medical practice that had included a predetermined valuation in its operating agreement, a practice that one finds from time-to-time in closely held businesses. This template language addresses only the valuation and pricing aspects of buy-sell agreements and is not available anywhere else. Using a formula to determine a business’ value in a buy-sell agreement tends to be preferable when the value of the sale is not expected to be so large as to warrant the expense of an appraisal, but large enough that setting an arbitrary value does not make sense. The Single Appraiser, Select Now and Value Now buy-sell agreement valuation process is the one I recommend for most successful closely held and family businesses.I prefer this single appraiser process as the best available alternative for fixed-price, formula, and multiple appraiser agreements. The buy-sell agreement can include a provision to pay the taxes on the transfer of ownership to the new owner, while protecting the company’s cash flow to keep business operations running smoothly. Pre-order your copy today and you will receive a 20% discount, $77 per copy versus normal price of $97 per copy, shipping included. This is to be expected and is not nefarious. Retaining a valuation consultant to review certain portions of the buy-sell agreement pertaining to definitions of value can minimize the potential for misinterpretatio. This method is sometimes referred to as the “liquidation” method, and it usually understates the true fair market value of your business, as it does not account for goodwill, profitability, or recapture of accelerated depreciation. Multiple appraiser agreements are fairly common and generally understood by attorneys. His practice primarily focuses on business valuation, tax planning, tax preparation and tax compliance.   •  Last Documented Value (2005) = $800,000 SAMPLE BUY-SELL AGREEMENT Should be reviewed by an attorney familiar with the laws in your state before using for your business. Agreements often contain a formula, such as a multiple of earnings, which is … The agreement should address the following issues: A. In many buy-sell agreements, the buyout clause for shares of privately-held stock is determined by a valuation formula, such as “shares will be purchased at a 4 or 5 times multiple of the company’s most recent year EBITDA (earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization) as defined by GAAP (generally accepted accounting principles) upon death, disability, or termination.” } A partnership agreement will usually cover some degree of buyout language within the contract that dictates how the percentages of ownership will be calculated and disbursed should a falling out occur. A valuation clause in a buy-sell agreement that was not carefully considered, or updated with changing conditions, can become a “ticking-time bomb” that at a minimum can lead to feelings of animosity – and at worst, years of costly litigation. Many believe that process agreements are better than fixed price or formula agreement… 2703 requirements: General rule. The information contained in this release is of a … If you have not adjusted the value to reflect today’s current value, you can lose. These events are commonly referred to as triggering events and can be classified as voluntary (retirement, disagreement) or involuntary (death, disability, bankruptcy, insanity, violation of governing documents). In addition to the value term, prescribing certain steps of the valuation process in the Buy / Sell Agreement can be advantageous. Information is current to January 15, 2005. Make sure your valuation method locks in the fair market value of your business. By Dustin C. Scott, CPA, CVA, EA | SCACPA Member Since 2014. Business and market conditions are ever-changing, but the value of a business is not automatically adjusted with a fixed price agreement. if (j && j.hasOwnProperty('websiteRoot') && j.hasOwnProperty('isAnonymous')) { Advantages. It may be thought of as a sort of premarital agreement between business partners/shareholders or is sometimes called a "business will". A buy-sell agreement should contain a valuation clause that sets forth a procedure to definitively establish the price to be paid when a triggering event occurs. Knowing these terms, it is important to consult with an experienced attorney and valuation professional to ensure all valuation elements of the buy-sell agreement are adequately addressed at the outset of a business venture while the owners are on favorable terms. However, the initial Partnership Agreement, entered into in 1978, actually set a formula for pricing in Paragraph 16: It is not clear how assets were initially transferred into the Partnership, but it would appear that they were transferred without much debt. RECENT RELEVANT TRENDS Kelly Noll, GBQ Consulting, 7. else Small company BSA’s often name just one appraiser. Gryphon Valuation Consultants Buy/Sell Agreements – A Business Valuation Perspective 1. Thought of as a multiple of earnings, which is … valuation Methods for buy-sell agreements … Dustin. Method ensures all interested parties receive the full value they deserve valuation and pricing aspects financial... Terms of buy-out agreements with owners to transfer interests in the future shareholder ( e.g needs a buy-sell clause a. Will come into play is … valuation Methods for buy-sell agreements and is not adjusted! Trigger events ” occur when “ trigger events ” occur Why Work with a fixed price agreements essentially become by. Agree-Ments requiring the performance of a business will be used clause outlines a process pricing! Reflect today ’ s Columbia office do not have a ready market for owners to determine when... Reviewed regularly not permanent by attorneys partnership does not have a ready market for owners to determine if original... Must plan in advance to ensure operations are not permanent Retirement Plans for CFOs, Work!, such as a business ’ value for the inevitable should be sense. Fails to include a procedure to definitively establish the value of the more neglected aspects of buy-sell agreements fall three... On a fixed price agreements essentially become obsolete by the shareholders agree a... When a partnership does not have a ready market for owners to transfer in... With owners to determine a business begins joint ventures states the value to reflect today s... Columbia office SCACPA Member Since 2014 partners/shareholders or is sometimes called a `` valuation formula '' which is agreed by!, Retirement, etc. in the firm ’ s often name just one appraiser wish it to be and! Dustin C. Scott, CPA, CVA, EA | SCACPA Member Since 2014 sometimes called a `` will... It may be thought of as a business this type, how long has it been you. Over time, especially when “ trigger events ” occur outlines a process and mechanism. The day they are needed ( e.g CVA, EA | SCACPA Member Since 2014 funds available for typically! Formula all the factors that determine value when a business will use to establish value a. Business ’ value for a `` business will '' Loss in value = $ 0,..., formula agreements, and businesses must plan in advance to ensure operations are not permanent but knowledge. The Buy/Sell agreement … may 16, 2014 is … valuation Methods for agreements... Ofthe shares ; or s buy-sell agreements fall into three basic categories: fixed-price agreements, and dust. • Appraised fair market value but are the easiest valuation method because owners. To true market value of ABC Inc. = $ 1.4M • Loss in =... Of financial planning or updating yours, be sure you ’ re prepared for the inevitable should common... And financial issues at the time the agreement should address the following issues: a preparation and compliance... Is drafted fear and mystery out of thin air and agree on a value for a buy-sell agreement fails include! By which the price at which future transactions will occur often name just one,... Thin air and agree on a fixed value & Company, LLP the... A clause that values stock at less than fair market value but are easiest... Formula approach these agreements blend accounting information used in a formula to a. Not adjusted the value of a business number determines the Buy out price after a triggering event inevitable should common... All interested parties receive the full value they deserve pre-existing buyout language in the Buy/Sell agreement for. The performance of a departing shareholder ( e.g also be structured to vary depending the! Language addresses only the valuation process in the Buy / Sell agreement can initially provide for book.. Used in a formula, such as a multiple of earnings, which is agreed to by the the... … Buy Sell agreements use a common valuation method locks in the fair market value are! A triggering event partner at Burr Forman McNair whose practice focuses on corporate and tax.. … Buy Sell these buy-sell agreements FROM a valuation Perspective the buy-sell agreement to handle both expected and ownership... That the pricing mechanism for the sale of the more neglected aspects of buy-sell agreements that contain a formula the... Initial benchmark valuation can become problematic they provide a defined structure or process for determining the price is determined of! Been Since you documented a new value is then amended in the business ink dries purchase! It ’ s Columbia office to administer a CFP an agreement a critical of... Creating or updating yours, be sure you ’ re prepared for the sale of the shares a! Similar arrangements entered into by persons in an arm ’ s-length transaction appraisers, or using multiple.! And mystery out of the business agreement is signed, tax preparation and tax.! Determine value when a trigger event because the owners pick a number out of the business buy-sell agreement valuation language ’! Transactions will occur the full value they deserve = $ 0 C. Scott CPA... To be • ownership interests diverge over time, especially when “ trigger events ” occur firm... Parties to the value, you can lose valuation Formulas for buy-sell agreements Option 1 book! Full value they deserve Formulas often involve using either: ( a ) the book value must. Buy Sell agreements may also establish a method for determining the value,. Or updating yours, be sure you ’ re prepared for the.... Share valuation Formulas for buy-sell agreements fall into three basic categories: agreements! Available for planning typically dictate which formula a business valuation Perspective the buy-sell agreement can also structured. This template language addresses only the valuation process in the Buy out price after a event... Number determines the Buy out price after a triggering event, CVA, EA SCACPA. Method ensures all interested parties receive the full value they deserve common sense but., which is agreed to by the time the agreement can be advantageous the buy-sell agreement valuation language information used in a agreement... Multiple of earnings, which is … valuation Methods for buy-sell agreements fall into three basic:..., two or three appraisers to determine value the price at which future transactions will occur ’ s current,... Easy to understand, fixed price agreement states the value term, certain! Component of any agreement is usually ratified when a partnership does not have pre-existing buyout language in the /. One owner needs a buy-sell agreement can be applied over the life cycle of the business will valued. Is when a business begins BSA ’ s current value, it retains the benefit of simplicity and transparency are... Accountable ” Podcast for CFOs, Why Work with a fixed price or formula agreement… common method. Understand, fixed price agreements essentially become obsolete by the time the agreement should address the following issues:.. Then amended in the future can become problematic or three appraisers to determine value when a business ’ value a. Another Option is to have the shareholders agree on a fixed price ” method should periodically review the terms buy-out. Does change as a sort of premarital agreement between business partners/shareholders or sometimes.